What the revisit taught me.
What I learned
The first version of Hotel Calm was designed from the outside in. I started with how it should look, then filled in the flow. Revisiting it showed me that the order should be reversed: understand the problem, decide what the user needs to know at each step, and let the visual design support that.
Three lessons stand out.
Copy is part of the design. "Small room / info" wasn't a placeholder problem, it was a thinking problem. Writing real room names and descriptions forced me to decide what actually matters to a guest.
Good ideas need complete execution. The confirmation panel was the strongest idea in the original, but it only confirmed half the booking. A half-built idea can create more doubt than no idea at all.
Competitors are a design resource, not just a benchmark. The Hoxton showed me what good looks like in the same segment. Booking.com showed me what to avoid. Mollie's showed me something I haven't acted on yet: that trust starts before the booking does.
What I'd do next
Test the redesign. The v2 is based on insights and competitor patterns, not user testing. My next step would be a round of usability testing with 5 users, measuring task completion time and where they hesitate in checkout.
Run an accessibility review. Text placed on imagery was a recurring pattern in the original. I'd check contrast, touch target sizes and screen reader flow across the full journey.
Design the before and after. Mollie's showed that trust is built before the booking starts. I'd explore how content and brand pages could lead users into the booking flow, and what happens after it: check-in, in-stay services, and the journey home.
Three years between the two versions, and the research didn't change. Only what I did with it.